So why do I tell everyone to go here when they visit Honolulu? Because if you go during Happy Hour or during their nightcap specials (i.e. when drinks/food are cheap) and have a drink while sitting outside looking out over the water with Diamond Head in the distance, it's pretty much impossible to be upset about anything (see the pictures?). If you sit close to the bar, it can get loud, though, so I recommend trying to find a seat outside. I have never had a problem finding a table outside (just a problem getting served).
I've never had dinner there and I rarely see people with entrees, but I have had lunch and I would recommend passing. The sandwich I ordered tasted fine, but what you get does not justify the cost. You're better off sticking to pre-dinner drinks/appetizers during happy hour (4-6pm M-F) or the nightcap specials (9:30-11:15pm M-F). Here is a copy of their happy hour menu if you're interested. Cocktails during this time are $5, draft beer is $3, house wine is $5, certain shots are $3, and appetizers (i.e. edamame, nachos, baby back ribs, chicken wings, fish tacos, chips and salsa, etc.) range from $4 to $10. Overall, if you can go and just relax and remember that you're not on the mainland and just enjoy the company and scenery, it's a must-go place. You can view their lunch menu here and dinner menu here.